A realist review of acute pain management in children and young people attended by ambulance
Nicholls G., Baliousis M., Bujor T., Eaton G., Hodgson J., Leighton P., Lord B., Ortega M., Redsell S., Siriwardena AN., Sumera K., Whitley GA.
Acute pain management in children and young people (CYP) attended by ambulance services is a significant challenge due to the complex nature of pain, the variation of approach needed across the age range, and the unpredictability of the environment. We aimed to understand how ambulance clinicians can provide improved prehospital acute pain management for CYP. A realist review was conducted and reported in accordance with the Realist And Meta-narrative Evidence Syntheses: Evolving Standards (RAMESES) guidance. We developed an initial programme theory (PT) using key stakeholder input, searched the major bibliographic databases MEDLINE, CINAHL Complete and PsycINFO, and other sources from January 2000 to February 2024, screened and assessed relevance and rigour in duplicate, and performed synthesis and programme theory refinement. We developed an initial PT that focussed on the preparedness of staff and the expectations of CYP and parents/carers, along with key outcomes such as pain score severity, fear and anxiety. The subsequent search strategy yielded 1503 documents, of which 95 were included, representing empirical research articles, reviews, theses, book chapters and clinical guidelines. The initial PT was tested and refined throughout the synthesis to produce a PT underpinned by 34 context-mechanism-outcome configurations. The PT portrayed positive (e.g. presence of parents, focussed education and training, building trust) and negative (e.g. misinformation, fear and anxiety, long-term consequences) effects on prehospital acute pain management for CYP. This PT was mapped to the Behaviour Change Wheel to provide a clinically relevant behaviour change model for improvement. This realist review has provided a clinically focussed model to guide the improvement of prehospital acute pain management in children and young people attended by ambulance. The programme theory lays a foundation on which future empirical testing can be conducted to effect behaviour change in practice. Registration: CRD42024505978.